Echoes of the Drum: Cultural Appropriation and the Liberal Gaze
In festival crowds and yoga studios, in craft fairs and eco-retreats, it is not uncommon to find white Americans wrapped in imitation turquoise, burning sage, or quoting Indigenous wisdom. They wear beaded earrings, attend sweat lodges, chant in languages they do not speak, and name their dogs after spirits from cultures they do not belong to.
Many do this with good intentions. They seek connection, grounding, or a more "authentic" way of life—one they believe Native traditions might offer. These individuals often align themselves with progressive politics, advocating for environmental protections, land acknowledgments, and Indigenous rights. But beneath this well-meaning surface lies a contradiction that deserves to be named.
They enjoy the privileges won through colonization while selectively adopting the symbols of the cultures in danger of being erased.
Performing Reverence Without Reparations
White liberal fascination with Indigenous culture can sometimes act as a balm for the settler conscience. It allows one to express admiration without surrendering power. It’s easier to hang a dreamcatcher than to return land. Easier to burn sage than to stop pipelines. Easier to quote Native wisdom than to sit with the violent truth of genocide.
This dynamic is especially problematic when commodification enters the equation. The market for "Native-inspired" goods is flooded with mass-produced imitations from non-Native sellers. Sacred objects—once earned, taught, or inherited—are rebranded as lifestyle accessories. A headdress becomes a costume. A ceremony becomes content. A culture becomes a product.
Privilege in Disguise
Someone who decorates their home with Navajo prints while living on unceded land may not see themselves as participating in colonization. But when Indigenous presence is aestheticized, abstracted, or romanticized—rather than engaged with directly—the harm persists. Cultural appropriation, even when "loving," is often just another form of erasure.
There is a danger in cherry-picking pieces of Indigenous identity that are palatable or pretty, while ignoring the structural violence that continues to harm Indigenous communities—especially when those communities are still actively fighting for recognition, sovereignty, and survival.
What Allyship Actually Looks Like
True respect means more than symbolic gestures. It means listening, giving space, deferring to real Indigenous voices, and materially supporting their struggles. It means examining one’s own inheritance of privilege—not just to feel guilt, but to take responsibility. It means understanding that while Native traditions may feel spiritually nourishing to outsiders, they are not up for grabs.
The question is not whether white people can learn from Indigenous cultures. The question is whether they are willing to unlearn the patterns of entitlement that made cultural appropriation feel like a right in the first place.